Thinking Inside the Box

A Paddocks Sectional Title Lifestyle Blog

“You’re blocking my view!” – Do you have the right to a view?

paddocks_blocked_view

By Zerlinda van der Merwe

Is there a building, structure or tree in your scheme that is obstructing your view of Table Mountain, the ocean, or the banks of the Vaal River? If the answer to this question is yes, then do you have a right to an unobstructed view from your unit? The answer to the latter question is not based in the provisions of the Sectional Titles Act (95 of 1986), but rather the principles of Common Law, namely the Law of Neighbours. Many principles of which are incorporated into the Sectional Titles Act, which regulates the relationship between neighbours in a community scheme.

We often deal with issues of dispute where one party is attempting the enforcement of the right to a view. However, as we advise these parties, there is no entitlement to the enjoyment of a view. In the English case of Dalton v Angus, Lord Blackburn made the statement that “a view was a matter of delight, and not necessity”.

For so long as an owner of land (or a unit) builds on, or uses their property, in a lawful, normal and reasonable manner, complying with the applicable building legislation and regulations, such as the National Building Regulations and Building Standards Act (103 of 1977), obstructing another’s view is not deemed to be nuisance or actionable harm.

In order to establish a cause of action, the complaining party would need to prove:

  • the existence of a servitude (for example a servitude of unrestricted view or a servitude of not building higher);
  • a registered restrictive condition;
  • the application of the provisions of a town planning scheme or other planning and building legislation; or
  • malicious intention to cause harm.

Complaining parties often challenge the local authority’s approval of building plans, attempting to raise issues such as incorrect procedure in considering plan approval, and the negative effect the proposed building would have on the market value of the neighbouring affected property. For example, if the proposed building would diminish a unit’s sea views.

The South African case of Paola v Jeeva is often cited as the leading authority for the protection of a right to a view. However, the success in this case was based on the argument that incorrect procedure was followed in the plan approval process, and not because the proposed building would have infringed the right to enjoy a view. Therefore, this case did not offer an indirect right to a view.

As mentioned at the beginning of this article, trees placed within a section or on common property within a scheme may also obstruct your view. An interesting article that deals with this problem was written by Anton Kelly.

Advertisements

6 comments on ““You’re blocking my view!” – Do you have the right to a view?

  1. Pingback: Why you do not have a right to a view – HomeTimes

  2. Helen Lindsay Hooper
    April 28, 2016

    If the Law does not support the right to a view, does it support the right to privacy? What if the neighbour’s alterations ,in a situation where units are very close together, results in overlooking someone else’s property?
    HLH

    • Paddocks
      May 3, 2016

      Dear Helen,

      Thanks for your question. In answer to your question, please take a look at our Paddocks Press article titled “The right to privacy“.

      Thanks,
      Paddocks

  3. Mpumzi
    April 26, 2016

    In the case where the section owner intentionally places a camera on the window of his property in order to “maintain surveillance” around his section, and the neighbourhood feel that their privacy is being violated, as the camera takes footage inside their sections because of close proximity of the sections. Your comments please.

  4. carel
    April 26, 2016

    A good article, but can you refer the well known Blaauwberg court case as well, where builder lost

    • Danie Oelofse
      April 26, 2016

      Hi please give details of this court decision referred to and the full article by Anton Kelly ,Thanks

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow us on Twitter

Address:

+27 (0)21 686 3950
Mon - Fri
8am - 5pm

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 426 other followers

%d bloggers like this: